• Follow us


Celebrate footy past, but don’t live in it

Port Adelaide will celebrate its 150th anniversary season next year. And there will be many who will challenge the Port Adelaide Football Club to stop “living in the past”.

Fox Footy and SEN senior editorialist Gerard Whateley emphasised this point last week as Port Adelaide was again appearing consumed by the backlash of a traditional fan base that wants the glory days from the SANFL to roll on in the national AFL.

“Stop the agitation; stop the unrest; stop this ridiculous idea that you’re this old SANFL club that should rule the world,” Whateley said. “That’s not you (Port Adelaide). That’s not you in the AFL.

“(In the national league) you scratch and you claw for everything that you’re worth. And you put a plan in place and you follow that plan through.”

Many of Port Adelaide’s traditionalists will struggle with this analysis.

They have lived through either the “Golden Era” of the 1950s and 1960s when the club’s patriarch Fos Williams, mainly with Geof Motley as captain, won 10 SANFL premierships and played in 17 grand finals from 1951-1972 — or with John Cahill masterminding another 10 flags from 11 SANFL grand finals from 1976 to AFL entry in 1997.

It is tough for many of these blessed fans to see their once-powerful football club that dominated a 10-team SANFL fall into the pack in an 18-club national AFL.

But it is not just Port Adelaide that has to deal with this reality that empires crumble in the national AFL.

The fulfilment of a national game — “Australia’s Game” — with AFL games in Victoria, NSW, Queensland, WA and SA from 1991 also has pulled down some of the VFL’s powerhouse clubs.

CARLTON. From 1970-1990 — a generation — the Blues played in eight grand finals and won six premierships. Only once did Carlton miss finals in consecutive seasons, 1989 and 1990 when the Blues ranked eighth.

Since 1991, Carlton has played in just three AFL grand finals, all in the 1990s decade — winning the flag in 1995. But the Blues have crashed under the demands of a national competition (and the pain of their salary cap penalties in 2001).

Carlton has collected wooden spoons — five of them, all in the AFL national era: 2002, 2005, 2006, 2015 and 2018. Welcome to the AFL, Carlton.

COLLINGWOOD. From 1970-1990, the VFL’s biggest club played in seven grand finals (including the 1977 replay) and, while suffering from the Colliewobbles, won only one flag — the 1990 premiership with an “outsider” from Hawthorn as coach, Leigh Matthews.

Since 1991, Collingwood has done better than Carlton to play finals in 14 seasons (including this one). But the Magpies have not been spared from a nightmare run either, such as seven consecutive years (1995-2001) without action in September. Current coach Nathan Buckley also went five seasons (2014-2017) without a top-eight finals appearance.

Welcome to the big league Carlton and Collingwood, two of the VFL’s proudest and most-successful clubs.

The jump from the SANFL to the national AFL has changed so much for Port Adelaide — as it has for Collingwood and Carlton that no longer dominate as they did in the VFL.

Port Adelaide — like Collingwood and Carlton — has much rich history and tradition to honour and celebrate in its 150th season next year. But the club cannot be held prisoner to its past.

Williams became the Port Adelaide Football Club’s modern patriarch by creating a new “Port Adelaide way” when he arrived as the “outsider” (from West Adelaide) in 1950. But there was no national draft, no salary cap and no need for the club to operate beyond Alberton to find a $60 million annual budgets.

Times change. And change demands great football clubs to adapt to the demands of a new era. Clearly, Collingwood has done such as the Eddie McGuire presidency has built a powerful sporting business that has advanced from the past at Victoria Park and with a blue-collar budget to find its future at the MCG and with the top-end of Australian and world corporate businesses.

From Hard Yakka overhauls to Gucci pinstripes. From Holden’s to Lexus. From mud on the terraces of inner suburban Melbourne to leather-lined seats in plush boxes at the MCG.

Carlton has not been as progressive, either in its off-field growth or with its football programs — and suffered for such.

Port Adelaide cannot live in the past. It should aim to win the AFL premiership every season. But to achieve this goal it needs to be accepting the need for change to adapt to a new era, one that goes as far as Shanghai, China.

Celebrating the past is appropriate in a 150th anniversary season. Living in the past just denies the Port Adelaide Football Club a meaningful future.

Welcome to the Roast, the ninth edition of the enewsletter delivered online every Tuesday.

This week, retiring Crows club champion Richard Douglas tells of the critical change to football in his 14 years in the big league — and why he wants the game to be about the players rather than the coaches’ strategic playbooks.

In Reality Bites, there is another fact-or-fiction tale with Crows coach Don Pyke, why Port Adelaide assistant coach Brett Montgomery is fine with the limit on the use of team runners and a grand Terry Wallace moment with the Western Bulldogs in 1996 has been repeated in the English Premier League.

The Roast will continue online at advertiser.com.au on Wednesday and Thursday.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Sport | News.com.au

Vautin: ‘Nothing can stop us’ New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Paul Vautin has declared “nothing can stop us’’ with the Manly legend predicting a fairytale finals series for the Sea Eagles.

Sky Racing Update – 20-09-19 New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Get all the latest racing information with the Sky Racing Update.

F1 star loses it over Ricciardo psych-out New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Daniel Ricciardo and Lando Norris set a dangerous precedent earlier in the season at the British Grand Prix drivers press conference, so it was only n

Outrage over ‘disgusting’ footy trip shirts New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03A NSW rugby league club has been ordered to destroy its end of season footy trip shirts following outcry over an offensive phrase on the top.

NRL clubs swarm $800k Broncos star New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Injury-prone star Jack Bird has immediately shown he still has some heat in the NRL with four clubs already chasing the star’s signature.

Super Titus win will flip Caulfield Cup markets: New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03David Hayes predicts dramatic change at the head of Caulfield Cup markets if Super Titus lands the MRC Foundation Cup.

Sheahan rips apart Cats champion New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Welcome to our live coverage of the AFL preliminary final between the Richmond Tigers and the Geelong Cats at the MCG, play gets underway at 7:50pm an

Inside mail: Punters go all in on Redzel New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03The battle for race favouritism between Redzel and Pierata in the betting ring is likely to be reflected in the Group 2 $500,000 The Shorts (1100m) at

Freddy fumes over fresh handshake-gate New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03South Sydney are red-hot favourites to continue Manly's ANZ Stadium hoodoo when they face off for a spot in the NRL final four on Friday night.

Fiji warn Wallabies: Attack us at your peril New! 2019-09-20 10:06:03Rugby’s greatest showmen have thrown down a cheeky challenge to the Wallabies — attack us at your peril.

The five Rugby World Cup games you won’t 2019-09-19 14:05:55We know you’ll be tuning in for the Wallabies, but what other Rugby World Cup games do you need to mark on your calendar?

RWC Countdown: ‘Mad’ Uruguay hoping for a World 2019-09-19 14:05:55In Uruguay, people say you’d have to be mad to play rugby, but despite a dearth of players the South American minnows have qualified for the Wor

Sydney Morning Herald RSS

NRL Elimination Final 2019 live: South Sydney Rabbitohs New! 2019-09-20 06:03:56It's all on the line as Souths host Manly at ANZ Stadium. The winner progresses to face Canberra but it's season over for the loser.

'How could I go to Vegas?' Moses stays New! 2019-09-20 06:00:00The Eels halfback handed back his ticket to a Conor McGregor fight in the US in the off-season to concentrate on himself. Now, the Eels are two wins a

Richmond v Geelong live: The battle for a New! 2019-09-20 05:42:15Geelong have taken the long road, while the Tigers are primed. Join us for live coverage as they clash for a spot in this year's AFL grand final.

All Blacks have nothing to worry about – New! 2019-09-20 05:41:01Just about everything points to another New Zealand win at the Rugby World Cup but they've stumbled before and, you never know, they might stumble ag

The world of Darcy Moore New! 2019-09-20 05:02:03Off-field, reading about international affairs is important for the Magpie defender. On-field, reading the play, combined with his athleticism, make h

Racing NSW right behind V'landys after re-signing CEO New! 2019-09-20 04:40:36Peter V'landys will begin as Australian Rugby League Commission chairman next month but he will remain chief executive of Racing NSW for at least the

Final chapters of inconsistent Wallabies World Cup cycle New! 2019-09-20 04:33:12Few could have imagined the Wallabies would register 20 victories from 47 Tests for a winning record of 42.6 per cent in the 1421 days since the 2015

'I just want to do what I love': New! 2019-09-20 04:00:00The former Sharks premiership-winning coach will be on the radar of a number of clubs and has been heavily linked to the Dragons.

The final questions: Collingwood v Greater Western Sydney New! 2019-09-20 03:54:00Depleted and angry the Giants will need everything to go right to overcome a settled Collingwood in the preliminary final and play in their first Gran

Tigers prepare for life without Matterson New! 2019-09-20 03:52:28Ryan Matterson's time at the Tigers is all but over as rival clubs prepare to pounce on the rising star.

Jahrome finds a new home in the eye New! 2019-09-20 03:29:53If you can survive a thundering high shot from Parramatta cult hero Maika Sivo, you can handle a little challenge like the switch to the Melbourne No.

Defender Francis commits to Bombers, Williams signs for New! 2019-09-20 03:12:06Essendon defender Aaron Francis has ended speculation about his future by signing a three-year contract with the Bombers.


From an almighty spray to a touchy-feely approach: 2019-09-19 18:52:05As elite athletes face more pressure than ever, the role of the coach is also evolving. And while an almighty spray and a heavy hand were once the nor

Rugby World Cup to kick off as Wallabies 2019-09-19 16:00:45The men's Rugby World Cup kicks off in Japan this evening, so how will the Wallabies go and can England be considered favourites ahead of New Zealand

AFL conspiracy theories mask combative edge to Collingwood 2019-09-19 15:35:08Ludicrous paranoia over the AFL's supposed favouritism for both Collingwood and GWS — depending on which fan you listen to — has added a

How a 'movement' of expressing vulnerability is empowering 2019-09-19 15:00:38A new willingness to open up about personal struggles and finding a rural sanctuary is empowering Richmond defender Dylan Grimes and his teammates.

FIFA tells Iran it is time to allow 2019-09-19 10:07:18Ever since a female soccer fan died after setting herself on fire to protest against her arrest for attending a match, demand has been growing for Ira

Toby Greene's appeal fails, ruled out of Giants' 2019-09-19 05:06:31Toby Greene will not play for Greater Western Sydney in Saturday's preliminary final against Collingwood after the AFL appeals board upholds his one-

Nicole Bolton was flying high as a national 2019-09-18 17:23:29Australian cricket great Nicole Bolton didn't know if she would ever play cricket again when she walked away from the sport last year after a crippli

The 2019 Ashes series will go down as 2019-09-18 16:21:56The 2019 Ashes series will not develop the cachet of 2005 in terms of consistently outstanding skill, but it will be revisited for its passages of pla

'In-flight entertainment on another level': Tongan rugby team 2019-09-18 03:04:51They are famous for being tough competitors on the playing field, and now Tonga's Rugby World Cup players are warming the hearts of the Japanese peop

Ben Stokes calls for media review after London 2019-09-17 23:21:00Ben Stokes's rollercoaster northern summer takes another turn, with the England star condemning a story by English tabloid The Sun that dredges up pa

Glenelg hopes to end premiership drought, Port Adelaide 2019-09-17 19:18:51A crowd of more than 40,000 is expected on Sunday as Glenelg seeks to end its SANFL premiership drought of 33 years and the Magpies fight off a hoodoo

Cancer survivor becomes first person to swim English 2019-09-17 19:16:18Sarah Thomas is recovering after swimming for more than 54 hours, being stung in the face by a jellyfish and surviving on an electrolyte formula tied

Sports - The Huffington Post

Patriots Player Antonio Brown's Former Trainer Accuses Him 2019-09-10 21:43:39In a lawsuit, Britney Taylor alleges that the NFL player sexually assaulted her in three separate incidents.

WNBA Player Astou Ndour Gets Ejected For Mind-Blowing 2019-09-09 11:04:25The Chicago Sky center ultimately got justice after the embarrassingly bad call.

Jets Fans Beg For Carli Lloyd After Kicker 2019-09-09 07:28:05The soccer star caught the interest of the NFL after booting a 55-yard field goal in practice.

Serena Williams Misses Out On History, Falls To 2019-09-07 18:23:53Andreescu is both the first Canadian to win a Grand Slam and the first player born in the 2000s to capture the honor.

This Bonkers College Kickoff Return Begins In The 2019-09-06 15:20:38Cory Carignan of Minot State was headed for disaster but became an ESPN highlight.

Laker Alex Caruso Gets Hit With Random Drug 2019-09-05 14:37:09The NBA guard playfully hinted that the timing might not be a coincidence.

Mets Fans Go To That Dark Place In 2019-09-04 06:19:55Wild card-chasing New York blew a 6-run lead in the ninth inning to the Washington Nationals, and the faithful vented.

Minor Leaguer's First Call-Up To Major Leagues Is 2019-09-03 11:01:53Sam Haggerty learned of his promotion to the New York Mets in a great setup speech from his manager, Tony DeFrancesco.

Carli Lloyd Shuts Down Doubts That She Could 2019-09-03 06:50:07The World Cup soccer star said she could take a hit in the NFL and deal with the pressure after a video of her practice with the Philadelphia Eagles w

Dwyane Wade And Pat Riley Dancing In Saint 2019-09-02 13:15:34The now-retired Miami Heat star and the barefoot coaching great wore "Aladdin"-like costumes.

Jackson State Mascot Penalized For Unsportsmanlike Conduct 2019-09-02 11:33:23Wavee Dave the Tiger got a little too caught up in the action after his team scored.

Andrew Luck's Letter To Indianapolis Colts Fans Is 2019-09-02 10:04:52The quarterback let out his feelings in a full-page newspaper ad farewell.

Sport | The Mercury

Tony Gollan: From Thurston to the Boom times New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16Tony Gollan has won the past six metropolitan training premierships in Brisbane and has trained Group 1 winners in the three eastern states of Austral

Why Crows can’t afford to pay unders any New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16As Adelaide mounts a charm offensive with estranged fans it’s also under pressure to abandon paying ‘unders’ for stars including clu

Caulfield tips: Everything you need for raceday New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16The impressive Pippie is still the standout selection with form analyst Michael Manley despite him be quite keen a couple of other runners at the Caul

No added pressure on boom NBA prospect New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16THE majority of American basketball fans are watching RJ Hampton’s every move this NBL season but the emerging star is not feeling any extra wei

Brothers to tussle it out for Freycinet Challenge New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16HOBART’S Alex Hunt will be striving for his fifth multisport Freycinet Challenge but hot on his heels this year will be his younger brother Robb

Rugby league can still use Jack Gibson’s wisdom New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16Jack Gibson had a wonderful knack for putting truth and simplicity in the same sentence.

5 things the Wallabies need to do to New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16DEFENCE

A classic contest of good against evil New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16What makes a great football club? It’s a question that footy scribes have grappled with for well over a century.

Whittaker within reach of world’s best tag New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16Forget best in Australia, Robert Whittaker is one win from becoming the greatest UFC fighter on the planet.

Seibold safe as Broncos board assess wreckage New! 2019-09-20 10:06:16Broncos coach Anthony Seibold on Friday fronted the Broncos board to deliver his blueprint to help the club recover from the wreckage of last Sunday&r

Ex-76er reacts to viral Simmons vid New! 2019-09-20 01:04:58Ex-Philadelphia 76ers shooting guard JJ Redick doesn’t generally put much weight on off-season hype videos, but vision of Ben Simmons confidentl

Live now: St James College v Churchie New! 2019-09-20 01:04:58The Molten Champion Basketball Schools Queensland continues today showcasing the best school talent in Queensland.

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.