• Follow us

Technology

How Tech Could Rescue the Awful Democratic Debates | Tech Buzz

Like many of you, I watched eight-plus hours of Democratic debates last week, and they seem to be getting worse over time. The last effort made it look like CNN was trying harder to create drama than to help people make a choice among the candidates.

We have a ton of technology -- some new, some in place for decades -- that could make this process far more informative and help people to make a decision that's right for them. It also might get people excited about the election, so they actually would vote.

I'll offer some ideas, as I did after the first round, on how we could use technology to make the debates more meaningful and improve the quality of our choices (we really need to improve the quality of our choices). I'll close with my product of the week: an interesting new smart tablet from Lenovo that thinks it's an Echo Show and arguably is a better value.

The Problem

The Democrats fielded a buttload of candidates who largely seem to be clones. This makes choosing among them difficult. Were it our job to make the choice (which it is), the debates so far haven't helped much.

The No. 1 thing that the Democrats want (and I expect not an insignificant number of independents and even moderate Republicans) is a replacement for Donald Trump. I mean, if the Democrats lose, it really doesn't matter what their candidate intended to do -- it won't get done.

Now that should make it pretty simple: Run largely on a platform of removing Trump from office, fixing what is perceived as broken, and not breaking stuff that isn't. Instead, the Democratic candidates seem to be focused on issues that will polarize the voters and have many thinking that the president is the better of two bad choices.

For instance, once again on healthcare (this was the problem with Obamacare), they are focusing on getting the government to pay for it rather than focusing on the real problem -- the excessive costs. We are the source of government funding, so just shifting the payee doesn't fix the real problem, given the money comes from us regardless.

There is also the issue of reparations, which would take money from folks who did no wrong and give it to folks who weren't harmed directly, and no one is talking about amounts. Rough calculations suggest that at US$500 million, it would only give between $10 and $20 per person (around 40 million black people in the U.S. = $12.50 per person at $500 million).

It would cost less than that per taxpayer (some of whom would be the people getting the money; a tax exclusively on white people would be, well, racist). The tax per person would be around $6.25 (assuming 80 million taxpayers) netting those who got the reparations around $6.25 each. Don't spend it all at once… . That assumes the collection and distribution of the money would be free, which it wouldn't be.

Yet if that money, all $500 million, were to go toward fixing education or reducing racial bias in the legal system or promoting more diversity in politics (note I'm saying "or" not "and," so it isn't diluted so much it can't make a difference) the impact would be far more meaningful. Without detailing what people will get, or what people will pay, any proposal is likely to create more conflict between the races (not enough paid out, too much paid in).

The candidates seem to have no idea that all the "Day One" stuff is B.S. For the first several weeks they'll be learning the job. Getting anything done, other than being sworn in, is unlikely, given how that first day goes.

In reality, folks don't care whether something is done on Day One or Day 300, as long as it gets done. Much of what is being promised won't get done at all, let alone on the first day. (The history of presidents keeping promises suggests most were just blowing hot air during their campaigns.)

Given the platforms, it really looks to me like the Democrats are trying to lose -- but be that as it may, here is how we could apply technology to help improve the process.

A BS Meter Application

It wouldn't be hard for a news service to create a B.S. meter. Using machine learning and working off campaign promises and the cumulative coverage of the candidates, an outlet could put up a running B.S. meter, much like The Washington Post's Pinocchio score (and it would be useful both for the primaries and the general election).

The system wouldn't be limited to showcasing whether what was said was true. It also could gauge whether promises made were achievable by probability. For instance, a lot of candidates made promises that Congress, which is dysfunctional and has been the bane of both parties' presidents, would have to enact -- and likely wouldn't.

The nice thing about a machine learning or deep learning artificial intelligence would be that it would learn over time, and that also would force the candidates to be more honest and realistic. I don't know about you, but I'm a tad tired of politicians who seem to get into office due to their ability to lie to us. Or, put another way, this could help change "honest politician" into something that isn't an oxymoron.

Virtual Debates

A few years back IBM demonstrated its Watson AI verbally debating a professional debater. While the system lost, it performed incredibly well. Most interesting was that the system was more entertaining than the human and arguably more accurate.

You could get that same system to emulate Trump and you could have a virtual debate between each of the prospective candidates and the virtual president. The result would provide a far better idea of which candidate could best counter Trump's unique style of manipulated facts and ad hominem attacks.

This also could help offset the perception problem with minority and woman candidates. Voters have locked into their heads what a president should look like, and that clearly is an old white guy. If done right, this approach could help broaden that perception to include a woman of color who, on paper, might be the strongest natural foil for President Trump. It would focus on performance first, however, better ensuring the intended outcome.

I'm actually surprised this isn't being done for debate preparation -- even if it weren't broadcast, the training would be invaluable.

Completed Thoughts

One of the real problems with the last debate was that the format was too tight, and candidates often were unable to complete a thought. Now the post-debate coverage could deal with that, but after five hours of the debate (with commercials), I'm not sure how many people would be hanging in. However, with the addition of active links, people could go and read what the candidate wasn't allowed to finish saying.

In addition, candidates could record complete answers after the fact, and much like an extended movie with added footage, there could be a post-debate experience that would give viewers more information on issues that concerned them. The 15-second rule was insane, in that it had no real connection to reality. One would need a ton of specialized training to be able to articulate complex thoughts consistently in 15 seconds.

An AI application could do it in real time, though, and if the AI could feed a display on the podium, the candidate then could pass on learning the 15-second skill and leave it to the AI, which could perform better. This also would be a great example of how to use AIs to help humans advance the technology, which is in an area the U.S. currently dominates (China is coming on fast though).

Instrument the Audience

One of the things I'm surprised hasn't happened yet is the creation of an app that would allow the audience to provide feedback on what they are seeing. The surveys on how people will vote aren't reliable, given there is just too much time between now and the election. However, it would be possible to monitor how perceptions were changing and report that in real time.

That way candidates could better hone their messaging. With results pooled by interests, people could see how their like-minded peers were trending, which might help them realize a candidate they liked actually wasn't right for them, and help them identify a candidate who would be better on merit, rather than on sex or race.

Aggregated Impact

One thing the current-generation system can do is take and parse a lot of information quickly and provide voters with an individual context at scale. What I mean is that a properly trained AI could consider your personal information and provide a ranking of the candidates based on which one proposed the path most favorable to you personally, based on your interests and investments. It also could adjust that for the likelihood of execution.

So, you'd get a ranking not only of who was listening more, but also of who was likely to accomplish more. For instance, both Sanders and Warren have similar aggressive policy proposals, but Warren is better integrated into the party and thus more likely to get done what she promises. That's an important distinction that likely is lost on most.

Once again, this would provide a strong counterpoint to voting based on physical appearance and likability to voting based on merit and ability to accomplish the tasks you, as a voter, want done. This would be useful for more than debates. It could be a website that voters could check periodically. It could go beyond the election, showing a running tab of how well the then-president was living up to promises made.

Wrapping Up

It continues to amaze me that while we are the world technology leader, we don't use technology better to ensure a well-run government. The last guy we elected was a reality-TV star. He doesn't like to read and arguably has created far more problems than he has fixed. That means the process is broken, and if we don't fix the process our happy future is anything but certain.

Technology, particularly artificial intelligence, is incredibly good at helping people make difficult decisions at scale. We need to apply it to the political process, so we are better able to pick candidates who don't just tell us what we want to hear but make actual progress. Without technology, that appears to be a bridge too far.

Rob Enderle's Product of the Week

Tablets at one time were expected to replace PCs, and they may at some future point -- once virtual windows rolls out. For now, they are mostly entertainment devices for watching videos, browsing the Web, and handling email.

My primary tablet is an Amazon Fire HD 10-inch tablet, and there are few places I go without it. While it isn't perfect, it does provide a lot of bang for the buck and sets a good baseline for what I need in a tablet.

Well, Lenovo has released an alternative in its Smart Tab. It's better made, with glass on both sides -- very rich feeling. It has a good display, a better cradle charger (with contacts rather than just a mini-USB port), and a similar implementation of Amazon Show to what the Fire Tablet has. The cradle also has better speakers, so you are more likely to use it instead of one of the Amazon devices. Connection to the cradle is through Bluetooth, and it auto-pairs when cradled.

Lenovo Smart Tab P10

Lenovo Smart Tab P10

While the glass on both sides makes this tablet look really cool, it makes it hard to carry. Finding a case that would work with the cradle was surprisingly difficult, but I did find one for under $20 on Amazon, and it seems to work incredibly well.

With the case, this product becomes really useful as a tablet. Without it, it is just an Amazon Show that is more portable and has a portable screen (granted, that might be enough for those who want this in the kitchen as kind of a small streaming TV, which is probably its best use case).

The display is decent, with 1,200 x 1,900 resolution and camera placement that makes it better than most tablets for video calls. (It also has a better microphone setup.) By the way, one cool use case is to start watching a video and then take the tablet with you with the video still running (like if nature suddenly calls) or you need to go to another room to do a project.

Unlike most Android tablets or Amazon tablets the Smart Tab blends the two ecosystems, giving you an impressive amount of application breadth.

At $283 on Amazon, it is a decent deal for those who want a bigger-screen Echo Show, and it kind of gives you an adequate tablet for $50 extra over the larger Echo Show.

Tablets that are better can be had, but they tend to price out at $500-plus, making this a bargain. I have a new favorite tablet, the Lenovo P10, and it is my product of the week.

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ECT News Network.

Rob Enderle has been an ECT News Network columnist since 2003. His areas of interest include AI, autonomous driving, drones, personal technology, emerging technology, regulation, litigation, M&E, and technology in politics. He has an MBA in human resources, marketing and computer science. He is also a certified management accountant. Enderle currently is president and principal analyst of the Enderle Group, a consultancy that serves the technology industry. He formerly served as a senior research fellow at Giga Information Group and Forrester. Email Rob.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechNewsWorld

Will Consumers Balk at 5G Phone Prices? 2019-08-23 06:24:57Consumers could suffer from sticker shock when it comes time to buy a 5G-enabled phone, suggests a new report from IHS Markit, based on a poll conduct

Major Browsers Block Kazakhstan Government's Fake Safety Cert 2019-08-22 05:50:09Google, Mozilla and Apple have blocked a fake root certificate issued by Kazakhstan's government to spy on its citizens' online activities. The gove

Fighting Cybercrime: Cybersecurity and Digital Forensics Are the 2019-08-21 14:11:02Cybersecurity and digital forensics are instrumental in creating effective defense, analysis and investigation of cybercrime. While both focus on the

Yubico Offers Dual Lightning, USB-C Dongle to Secure 2019-08-21 06:12:03Owners of iPhones looking for an extra measure of protection when using applications and logging into websites can get it with a new dongle from Yubic

Cerebras Debuts Big Chip to Speed Up AI 2019-08-20 05:36:12Startup chip developer Cerebras has announced a breakthrough in high-speed processor design that will hasten the development of artificial intelligenc

Sanity-Saving Tips From a Heavy Traveler 2019-08-19 13:24:32I'm on the road about 50 percent of the time, and I'm often asked for advice on how to have a better trip -- what to carry with you, where to sit, h

Slackel Linux Works Well Inside Its Openbox 2019-08-16 13:46:17The latest release of Slackel Linux renews and improves the mashup of Slackware and Salix built around an Openbox pseudo desktop environment. Slackel

YouTube as Political Influencer Takes the Spotlight 2019-08-16 05:45:44YouTube, which operates as one of Google's subsidiaries, is under increased scrutiny after a report earlier this month highlighted the role it played

28M Records Exposed in Biometric Security Data Breach 2019-08-15 05:31:13Researchers associated with vpnMentor, which provides virtual private network reviews, discovered a data breach involving nearly 28 million records in

How to Distro Hop With a Web Browser 2019-08-14 14:54:57Getting familiar with Linux up close and personal is easy to do with a free service provided by DistroTest.net, which allows testing without ISO downl

Snap Unwraps $380 High-Tech Specs 2019-08-14 05:56:39With the announcement of its Spectacles 3 sunglasses, Snap must be hoping three times will be the charm. Unlike the two previous generations, Spectacl

Samsung Announces Monster 108MP Smartphone Sensor 2019-08-13 13:39:22Samsung and Xiaomi have announced a new sensor for smartphone cameras comparable to those used in high-end DSLR shutterboxes. The new Isocell Bright H

PCWorld

Best cheap laptops: We rate the best-sellers on 2019-08-22 21:58:00When you’re looking for a good, cheap laptop, knowledge is power. Every budget machine (which we’re defining as Windows laptops costing $5

Best power banks of 2019: The top USB 2019-08-22 13:44:00Anyone who uses a smartphone knows the importance of carrying a backup power bank. But given the large number of options on Amazon, you might feel ove

Watch The Full Nerd talk about Comet Lake, 2019-08-22 13:39:00Join The Full Nerd gang as they talk about the latest PC hardware topics. On today's episode we talk about the Intel Comet Lake news, Jensens' rant

Bose’s first portable smart speaker is slated for 2019-08-22 11:23:00Get ready to take Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant on the road in Bose’s just-announced portable smart speaker, due to arrive next month.

Best smart speakers: Which deliver the best combination 2019-08-22 10:54:00With models based on Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri, Cortana, and others to come, we’ll help you find just the right model for you.

Goodbye Android Q, hello Android 10: Google's dessert-based 2019-08-22 10:43:00After six betas, there isn’t much we don’t know about the next version of Android, but there was still one burning question: What dessert

Mophie Powerstation XXL review: This is the portable 2019-08-22 06:30:00The last time I tested a portable battery from Mophie was in 2017 when I reviewed the Powerstation Plus XL. It was impressive enough to earn PCWorld&r

Frndly TV: A cheap way get Hallmark Channel, 2019-08-22 06:00:00With the Hallmark Channel and more for $6 per month, Frndly TV is the cheapest live TV streaming bundle yet.

Amazon Echo Auto review: Alexa just doesn't deliver 2019-08-22 06:00:00The Amazon Echo Auto brings Alexa into your car, but it relies too much on your existing technology to be of much use.

Best TV streaming service: YouTube TV vs. SlingTV 2019-08-22 06:00:00Is Sling TV better than Hulu, or should cord-cutters subscribe to PlayStation Vue? Or YouTube TV? We compare all the TV streaming services, and severa

Acer Aspire 5 A515-54-30BQ review: A dual-core laptop 2019-08-22 06:00:00It won’t win any speed records, but the Acer Aspire 5 A515-54-30BQ makes for a compelling bargain-priced laptop all the same. This $400 model of

Best water leak detectors for smart homes 2019-08-21 14:50:00Fires can be devastating, but water damage is a far more common risk. These smart devices will alert you if your home springs a leak, so you can take

FOX News

Google removes 210 YouTube channels in Hong Kong 2019-08-22 20:25:27Google said Thursday that it had shut down 210 YouTube channels after the company learned they were tied to misinformation about the pro-democrac

Snapchat used by arms traffickers to market illegal 2019-08-22 17:37:59A Nevada man used Snapchat to market illegal weapons to buyers in California, according to a new report.

Apple iPhone 7 radiation test prompts FCC investigation: 2019-08-22 16:52:42Apple's popular iPhone 7 produced radiofrequency radiation above the legal limit in a new test, prompting the FCC to investigate the issue.

Army sets sights on lasers for infantry troops 2019-08-22 16:19:56U.S. Army Infantry units fight door-to-door in Close-Quarter-Combat in high-threat urban environments, advance through wooded, rocky terrain to maneuv

Turn off your Bluetooth, warn security experts 2019-08-22 12:09:48Your Bluetooth connection is unsafe. Very unsafe. That’s the message from the largest hacker convention.

Election machine keys are on the Internet, hackers 2019-08-22 09:14:50I may have the keys to open voting machines used in states across the country, and that is not a good thing.

Fake news can lead to false memories, new 2019-08-21 19:03:59Voters could form false memories after seeing fabricated news stories if those articles align with their existing political beliefs, according to newl

F-35 set for laser boost 2019-08-21 16:22:39Fighter Jet laser weapons are on the fast track, expected to bring new air attack options to “burn holes” through enemy targets at the spe

YouTube pressured to kick Chinese state media ads 2019-08-21 16:10:43YouTube users are pressuring the video platform to take down advertisements for China Central Television (CCTV), a state media channel accused of

Bunny or bird: What do you see in 2019-08-21 10:25:07Is it a bird? Or is it a bunny?

Apple Card starts rolling out for some users 2019-08-06 08:28:06Apple began to roll out its entry into the credit card business, Apple Card, on Tuesday, following comments from CEO Tim Cook last month.

YouTube removes far-right creator Soph's account for hate 2019-08-05 17:50:55Google-owned YouTube has taken down the account of a teenage creator after she posted a video that seemed to call for violence against LGBT people.

TechCrunch

Uber tries to reassure customers that it takes 2019-08-24 16:35:21It’s hard at times not to feel sorry for Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi, given all that he inherited when he became the ride-share giant’s top

Y Combinator Demo Day, revenue-based VC funding, Pivotal, 2019-08-24 14:36:58Editor’s note Due to bad travel logistics (thanks SFO), I wasn’t able to get the mid-week edition of the Extra Crunch roundup newsletter o

The new Disney+ streaming service is oriented around 2019-08-24 14:24:54You can tell a lot about a service by what it prioritizes on its home screen. With the new Disney + service the focus is initially organized by fan ba

Driving Volkswagen’s all-electric ID Buggy concept 2019-08-24 13:00:27The VW electric ID Buggy concept is delightful and bright, stout and smiling. It’s a vehicle fit for the sunshine and sand dunes, or perhaps a l

Startups Weekly: Diamond-encrusted disruption 2019-08-24 08:00:32In this week's newsletter: Andreessen Horowitz's latest investment, Pietra, is tackling the $250 billion jewelry market.

Graphcore founder Nigel Toon to talk about AI 2019-08-24 04:01:12It’s easy to forget that Silicon Valley starts with ‘silicon’, and that there would be no technology innovation without innovation a

Confirmed: Disney is making an Obi-Wan series with 2019-08-23 20:38:06The rumors have been suggesting it for a while now, and fans have been pretty much begging for it… and it’s happening: Ewan McGregor will

Here’s the first trailer for the upcoming Disney+ 2019-08-23 20:27:01It’s here! About ten months after we learned that Jon Favreau would be heading up a Star Wars series called “The Mandalorian” on Dis

Vape lung has claimed its first victim, and 2019-08-23 19:57:01A person has died from what the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention speculate is a vaping-related condition. Nearly 200 other cases of varying

Disney introduces “She Hulk”, “Moon Knight” and “Ms. 2019-08-23 19:56:56As part of its big reveal of the slate of shows coming to Disney+ streaming service, Marvel head Kevin Feige introduced three new shows that would be

Trump adds tariffs to $550 billion of Chinese 2019-08-23 19:51:42President Trump announced Friday on Twitter that tariffs on Chinese imports will increase 5 percentage points in a tit-for-tat response to China&rsquo

Bag Week 2019: A whole bunch of fannies 2019-08-23 18:05:11It’s finally Bag Week again! The most wonderful week of the year at TechCrunch. Just in time for back to school, we’re bringing you r

Electrek

Tesla updates its Autopilot auto lane change animation 2019-08-24 15:34:05 Tesla has made a slight update to its Autopilot auto lane change animation in a new software update this week. more… Subscribe to Electrek on

Tesla Sentry Mode helps police in break-in – 2019-08-24 12:21:21 Tesla Sentry Mode, a security system built into Tesla vehicles, has helped the police in another Tesla break-in in California. Learn people, stop bre

Climate Crisis Weekly: Amazon rain forest fire, the 2019-08-24 09:00:11 In this edition of Climate Crisis Weekly: Just in case you didn’t hear, the Amazon rain forest is on fire. The other Amazon — you know, J

Podcast: Tesla this week, Mercedes-Benz electric minivan, Porsche 2019-08-23 15:36:59 This week on the Electrek Podcast, we discuss the most popular news in the world of sustainable transport and energy, including all the news fro

Tesla announces expansions in Poland, Hungary, Romania, and 2019-08-23 14:15:41 Tesla is finally expanding in Eastern Europe by making its vehicles available to order in Poland, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia starting now. more&h

EGEB: Bernie Sanders’ Green New Deal, Apple’s solar 2019-08-23 14:00:15 In today’s Electrek Green Energy Brief (EGEB): Bernie Sanders announces his Green New Deal. Apple develops rooftop solar for Taiwanese soy sauc

Add Sun Joe’s 14A Electric Pressure Washer to 2019-08-23 13:24:50 Amazon offers the Sun Joe 2030PSI 14A Electric Pressure Washer for $124 shipped. Also at Walmart. Originally $199, it more recently sells for ar

Tesla and Walmart are looking to re-energize 240+ 2019-08-23 12:55:42 Earlier this week, we reported on a dispute between Tesla and Walmart over problems with a massive amount of solar power systems the former installed

Audi teases new electric off-roader and it looks 2019-08-23 12:05:01 Audi is going to bring a few new electric vehicles to the IAA Frankfurt Motor Show next month and today, it teased one of those EVs: an insane-lookin

Toyota will deploy 850 electric vehicles at the 2019-08-23 10:16:04 Toyota is providing the official fleet for the Olympic and Paralympic Games in Tokyo in 2020 and 90% of them will be electric. That’s 850 elect

Electric V2G school bus pilots grow, but schools 2019-08-23 08:29:39 “The batteries on this bus go bi-directional!” That’s what kids in White Plains School District, just north of New York City, can b

Tesla makes battery supply deal with LG for 2019-08-23 05:45:48 Tesla has reportedly signed a battery supply deal with LG Chem for Gigafactory 3 in China. It would be Tesla’s first deal to supply battery cel

Ars Technica UK

The Pebble Beach Concours in pictures: plenty of 2019-08-24 14:40:35But why didn't the world's most beautiful car win best in show?

Ewan McGregor confirms he will return as Obi-Wan 2019-08-24 13:20:56Plus first trailers for What If...? and The Mandalorian; more new series under way.

A lone gunman roams a galaxy in chaos 2019-08-24 10:15:44New series takes place a few years after the fall of the Empire.

Our favorite gaming studios, expos, museum exhibits—in a 2019-08-24 09:00:55Flip through nearly a decade of costumed fans, rare consoles, and much more.

Tracking online hate groups reveals why they’re resilient 2019-08-24 08:15:53When Facebook kicked the KKK, it re-formed on a Russia-based social network.

Book publishers sue Audible to stop new speech-to-text 2019-08-24 07:55:27Publishers say Audible's new captions feature is illegal. Is it?

Why people keep falling for viral hoaxes 2019-08-24 07:15:25How did this latest Instagram hoax spread? Simple: Our dumb brains.

Hackers are actively trying to steal passwords from 2019-08-24 06:30:34Got Fortigate or Pulse Secure? Now would be a good time to make sure they're patched.

Deadly superbug outbreak in humans linked to antibiotic 2019-08-23 17:15:18Use of certain antibiotics in cattle increased 41% just before the outbreak.

Hundreds of “banned” goods still for sale on 2019-08-23 16:08:32WSJ report finds "flea market" environment with scant oversight for merchants.

Vaping-linked lung disease cases jump from 94 to 2019-08-23 16:05:09That's a 60% rise in cases in five days; CDC has since reported even more probable cases.

US phone carriers make empty, unenforceable promises to 2019-08-23 15:51:51All 50 states agree to let telcos keep doing what they're already doing.


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.