• Follow us


What the CBS Blackout Means for the Future of Streaming | Online Entertainment

CBS earlier this week went dark across AT&T's U-verse and DirecTV services, days after the seven-year contract between the two companies expired. As the two couldn't come to new terms, CBS and its related channels -- including CBSN, CBS Sports and The Smithsonian Channel -- were blacked out.

This latest disruption in service affected viewers in major markets across the United States, including New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Philadelphia, Dallas, San Francisco, Boston, Atlanta, Tampa, Seattle, Detroit, Minneapolis, Miami, Denver, Sacramento, Pittsburgh and Baltimore. In total, 117 CBS stations have been affected.

As with other service blackouts, there already has been finger pointing between the two sides. CBS has accused AT&T of proposing unfair terms, while AT&T has said that CBS is at fault for being a repeat blackout offender. CBS in fact has pulled its stations from DISH Network and Charter Spectrum in the past.

AT&T also accused CBS of unprecedented fee increases, warning that they could soar nearly 60 percent in the next 18 months. CBS maintained that the previous deal, which was signed in 2012, was not close to today's fair market terms for the content provided.

Blackouts Are the New Normal

This showdown between AT&T and CBS -- and the subsequent blackout of content -- is just the latest high-profile impasse between a pay-TV service and a content provider. Just 20 years ago it was almost unheard of for such a thing to occur, but in the spring of 2000 Disney-owned ABC briefly pulled content from Time Warner Cable.

At the time the blackout of content was seen as the "nuclear option," but today it is far more common for content providers to, in essence, pick up their marbles and go home.

"That is undoubtedly the case," said Dan Cryan, principal analyst at MTM London.

"This has become the modally standard part of the strategy to negotiate in public," he told TechNewsWorld.

"Most of the negotiations happen behind closed doors, but once these break down it moves to the public arena, and the threat is to withdraw -- and that has become part of the standard playbook," added Cryan.

Once the blackout occurs it affects the viewer directly.

Back in 2000 the only recourse for those who couldn't miss the then-hit series Who Wants to be a Millionaire? was to grab the rabbit ears and get ABC over-the-air.

Fast-forward to 2019, and disputes between the service providers and content providers have only escalated. HBO went dark for the first time ever on a pay-TV service last fall, after it and DISH Networks failed to come to terms. Ironically, HBO is owned by AT&T -- so the dynamics and grievances have flipped somewhat.

However, there is still some independence between Time Warner Media and its parent company AT&T, explained Cryan.

"This tactic does seem to be more common than it used to be," he noted.

From 'Please Carry' to 'Pay to Carry'

One reason that blackouts of content weren't really a thing until about 20 years ago is that in the early days of pay-TV services the local stations wanted to be carried, as did the broadcasters. It provided a way for more eyeballs to view the content.

"The times change, don't they?" observed Cryan.

"There has been this incremental shift where we moved from 'please carry' to broadcasters being widely carried to the downturn in ads, and suddenly that was made up with carriage revenue," he explained.

"Those fees have gone up significantly as ad revenue has fallen," Cryan pointed out. "What we've seen is a shift to broadcasters getting paid for the retransmission, but it has come at a cost."

This isn't just the cost that pay-TV services are paying. In other markets -- notably in Europe -- broadcasters have not been pushing technological development vigorously. This is changing in the U.S., as broadcasters see opportunities to reach audiences via streaming services.

OTT to the Rescue

One significant difference between the first major blackout of content in 2000 and this week's blackout is that viewers have more alternatives in 2019 -- even if some are costly. One solution is to go with an over-the-top streaming service -- something DISH actively promoted to its subscribers who simply couldn't miss HBO's Game of Thrones this spring.

It solved a problem. AT&T/HBO demanded DISH pay a fee for every one of its subscribers, even those who didn't want HBO, which DISH refused to do. HBO Now, a US$7.99 a month streaming service, is an option for cord cutters who have ditched traditional pay-TV services.

This is viewed as a disruption to the pay-TV business. It's possible AT&T could be hurting its own business model by driving CBS viewers to CBS All Access, the network's own streaming service.

"The question is the degree to which consumers value content other than CBS, and whether CBS will be missing permanently from the AT&T lineup," said Brett Sappington, principal analyst at Parks Associates.

"Those consumers that subscribe to pay-TV primarily to get CBS have probably already cut the cord for CBS All Access," he told TechNewsWorld. "The remainder likely value the rest of the content in their channel package. This remainder will likely pay $5.99 per month along with their pay-TV subscription if they believe the situation is short term. The longer it lingers, the more likely they will be to switch to a different provider that has CBS."

The Price and Cost of Streaming

When Netflix launched its OTT streaming service, it initially was seen as a replacement for its DVD-by-mail business, but it soon began producing original content.

Now OTT is an alternative platform from cable, with numerous players getting on board. In addition to the established competition from Amazon and Hulu, upstarts including Sony Crackle and Acorn TV have entered the fray, and Disney and Apple soon plan to launch services.

Meanwhile CBS, AMC, FX, HBO and countless other traditional cable/satellite channels also have jumped on the bandwagon. These channels don't want to lose the eyeballs of people who cut the cord, so they are offering alternative methods for viewers to receive the content.

The issue for consumers/viewers -- beyond the fact that there are only so many hours in a day to binge on TV programs -- is that each service has its own fee. Cutting the cord and opting for even a few OTT services could cost as much as a cable bundle!

As result, OTT services could see $9.1 billion in lost revenue due to piracy and illicit account-sharing this year, and that number could increase to $12.5 billion by 2024, according to a recent study by Parks Associates.

"Consumers typically turn to piracy when there are no legitimate options open, particularly free options," warned Sappington.

Back to an Ad-Based Business

Some OTT services have opted to offer a more affordable option -- in some cases even free -- that allows viewers to see ad-supported content. In some ways this solves a problem that has affected ad-supported channels and broadcasters since the late 1990s -- notably the use of DVRs to skip commercials.

Viewers still can get the benefit of time-shifting programs to suit their needs, and even the ability to location-shift to watch shows elsewhere, but the tradeoff is that they can't zoom past commercials. For many consumers who want to pay less, this could be the best solution.

"Ad-based options from a legitimate source can be more appealing than the potential risks of a pirate website," said Sappington.

"Ads are a possibility to the same extent as they were before," said Pedro M. Ferreira, associate professor in the department of engineering and public policy at Carnegie Mellon University.

"Consumers have already shown that they are often willing to pay with their time -- watching ads -- instead of money, so certainly some users will prefer a lower fee and ads," he told TechNewsWorld.

"The share of consumers that will prefer so increases with the fee, which may indeed be significant in the case of multiple 'must see' shows spread across several platforms," noted Ferreira, who coauthored an article, "The Impact of Time Shifting on TV Consumption and Ad Viewership" for the journal Management Science.

Free is better than the alternative.

"Piracy will also increase because some consumers will pay one or two fees and become affiliated with a couple of platforms and pirate everything else," Ferreira added.

Ads also could be less of an issue for younger viewers who are known to multi-task.

"There is evidence that the younger generation watches several shows 'at the same time' and watches some shows at twice the speed," said Ferreira.

This could present problems for advertisers, especially if the ad time is used to do something else.

"I anticipate that they may be doing something else on a second screen while the ads come up, which decreases dramatically their efficacy, lowering the click-through rate to a level that requires rethinking ads altogether," Ferreira suggested.

One-Show Services

The blackout AT&T's service could help drive more viewers to CBS All Access -- notably those who have thought about checking out the service for Star Trek Discovery or The Twilight Zone, but felt that one or two shows weren't enough to justify the costs.

That has been a problem for streaming services. One show, even a marquee title that has earned rave reviews and racked up awards, might not be enough of a draw -- at least not when it means another subscription.

Still, more than a quarter of viewers can be drawn in by the right program.

"In fact, 28 percent of consumers said they have subscribed to an OTT streaming service for a single title," noted Parks Associates' Sappington.

"The job of the streaming service is to show that 28 percent why they should continue to subscribe," he added.

However, that poses another problem.

"Original programming is a large factor in account-sharing, particularly for tentpole content," said Sappington.

"This differentiation strategy, in which each platform has its own exclusive 'must see' show, may also backfire, reducing the platforms' ability to introduce ads," explained CMU's Ferreira.

Back to Bundles

The resurgence of ad-supported programming and the plethora of streaming services could usher in a new era of bundling content.

Amazon already offers premium content from the likes of HBO, Cinemax and other paid-TV premium channels. There is the possibility that this could continue. Instead of cable or satellite, bundles could come via streaming services.

"It could still very much depend on the channel," said MTM London's Cryan.

"For premium channels there are already direct-to-consumer streaming options, but that is very different from ESPN or even AMC, which -- while there are streaming versions -- are still much more tied into a core bundle," he added.

What we could see instead are more a la carte options -- but that raises the same question. In the early 1980s, it was how many premium channels a family could afford with a cable package. Today that question is how many streaming services can one support, even in a bundled situation.

"We're still in the middle of a rush of direct-to-consumer subscriptions," said Cryan, "but there is a limit of what they're willing to pay for, and what content each has to offer. There is still a real concern that we're going to face subscription fatigue."

Peter Suciu has been an ECT News Network reporter since 2012. His areas of focus include cybersecurity, mobile phones, displays, streaming media, pay TV and autonomous vehicles. He has written and edited for numerous publications and websites, including Newsweek, Wired and FoxNews.com. Email Peter.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


Will Consumers Balk at 5G Phone Prices? 2019-08-23 06:24:57Consumers could suffer from sticker shock when it comes time to buy a 5G-enabled phone, suggests a new report from IHS Markit, based on a poll conduct

Major Browsers Block Kazakhstan Government's Fake Safety Cert 2019-08-22 05:50:09Google, Mozilla and Apple have blocked a fake root certificate issued by Kazakhstan's government to spy on its citizens' online activities. The gove

Fighting Cybercrime: Cybersecurity and Digital Forensics Are the 2019-08-21 14:11:02Cybersecurity and digital forensics are instrumental in creating effective defense, analysis and investigation of cybercrime. While both focus on the

Yubico Offers Dual Lightning, USB-C Dongle to Secure 2019-08-21 06:12:03Owners of iPhones looking for an extra measure of protection when using applications and logging into websites can get it with a new dongle from Yubic

Cerebras Debuts Big Chip to Speed Up AI 2019-08-20 05:36:12Startup chip developer Cerebras has announced a breakthrough in high-speed processor design that will hasten the development of artificial intelligenc

Sanity-Saving Tips From a Heavy Traveler 2019-08-19 13:24:32I'm on the road about 50 percent of the time, and I'm often asked for advice on how to have a better trip -- what to carry with you, where to sit, h

Slackel Linux Works Well Inside Its Openbox 2019-08-16 13:46:17The latest release of Slackel Linux renews and improves the mashup of Slackware and Salix built around an Openbox pseudo desktop environment. Slackel

YouTube as Political Influencer Takes the Spotlight 2019-08-16 05:45:44YouTube, which operates as one of Google's subsidiaries, is under increased scrutiny after a report earlier this month highlighted the role it played

28M Records Exposed in Biometric Security Data Breach 2019-08-15 05:31:13Researchers associated with vpnMentor, which provides virtual private network reviews, discovered a data breach involving nearly 28 million records in

How to Distro Hop With a Web Browser 2019-08-14 14:54:57Getting familiar with Linux up close and personal is easy to do with a free service provided by DistroTest.net, which allows testing without ISO downl

Snap Unwraps $380 High-Tech Specs 2019-08-14 05:56:39With the announcement of its Spectacles 3 sunglasses, Snap must be hoping three times will be the charm. Unlike the two previous generations, Spectacl

Samsung Announces Monster 108MP Smartphone Sensor 2019-08-13 13:39:22Samsung and Xiaomi have announced a new sensor for smartphone cameras comparable to those used in high-end DSLR shutterboxes. The new Isocell Bright H


Best cheap laptops: We rate the best-sellers on 2019-08-22 21:58:00When you’re looking for a good, cheap laptop, knowledge is power. Every budget machine (which we’re defining as Windows laptops costing $5

Best power banks of 2019: The top USB 2019-08-22 13:44:00Anyone who uses a smartphone knows the importance of carrying a backup power bank. But given the large number of options on Amazon, you might feel ove

Watch The Full Nerd talk about Comet Lake, 2019-08-22 13:39:00Join The Full Nerd gang as they talk about the latest PC hardware topics. On today's episode we talk about the Intel Comet Lake news, Jensens' rant

Bose’s first portable smart speaker is slated for 2019-08-22 11:23:00Get ready to take Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant on the road in Bose’s just-announced portable smart speaker, due to arrive next month.

Best smart speakers: Which deliver the best combination 2019-08-22 10:54:00With models based on Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri, Cortana, and others to come, we’ll help you find just the right model for you.

Goodbye Android Q, hello Android 10: Google's dessert-based 2019-08-22 10:43:00After six betas, there isn’t much we don’t know about the next version of Android, but there was still one burning question: What dessert

Mophie Powerstation XXL review: This is the portable 2019-08-22 06:30:00The last time I tested a portable battery from Mophie was in 2017 when I reviewed the Powerstation Plus XL. It was impressive enough to earn PCWorld&r

Frndly TV: A cheap way get Hallmark Channel, 2019-08-22 06:00:00With the Hallmark Channel and more for $6 per month, Frndly TV is the cheapest live TV streaming bundle yet.

Amazon Echo Auto review: Alexa just doesn't deliver 2019-08-22 06:00:00The Amazon Echo Auto brings Alexa into your car, but it relies too much on your existing technology to be of much use.

Best TV streaming service: YouTube TV vs. SlingTV 2019-08-22 06:00:00Is Sling TV better than Hulu, or should cord-cutters subscribe to PlayStation Vue? Or YouTube TV? We compare all the TV streaming services, and severa

Acer Aspire 5 A515-54-30BQ review: A dual-core laptop 2019-08-22 06:00:00It won’t win any speed records, but the Acer Aspire 5 A515-54-30BQ makes for a compelling bargain-priced laptop all the same. This $400 model of

Best water leak detectors for smart homes 2019-08-21 14:50:00Fires can be devastating, but water damage is a far more common risk. These smart devices will alert you if your home springs a leak, so you can take

FOX News

Google removes 210 YouTube channels in Hong Kong 2019-08-22 20:25:27Google said Thursday that it had shut down 210 YouTube channels after the company learned they were tied to misinformation about the pro-democrac

Snapchat used by arms traffickers to market illegal 2019-08-22 17:37:59A Nevada man used Snapchat to market illegal weapons to buyers in California, according to a new report.

Apple iPhone 7 radiation test prompts FCC investigation: 2019-08-22 16:52:42Apple's popular iPhone 7 produced radiofrequency radiation above the legal limit in a new test, prompting the FCC to investigate the issue.

Army sets sights on lasers for infantry troops 2019-08-22 16:19:56U.S. Army Infantry units fight door-to-door in Close-Quarter-Combat in high-threat urban environments, advance through wooded, rocky terrain to maneuv

Turn off your Bluetooth, warn security experts 2019-08-22 12:09:48Your Bluetooth connection is unsafe. Very unsafe. That’s the message from the largest hacker convention.

Election machine keys are on the Internet, hackers 2019-08-22 09:14:50I may have the keys to open voting machines used in states across the country, and that is not a good thing.

Fake news can lead to false memories, new 2019-08-21 19:03:59Voters could form false memories after seeing fabricated news stories if those articles align with their existing political beliefs, according to newl

F-35 set for laser boost 2019-08-21 16:22:39Fighter Jet laser weapons are on the fast track, expected to bring new air attack options to “burn holes” through enemy targets at the spe

YouTube pressured to kick Chinese state media ads 2019-08-21 16:10:43YouTube users are pressuring the video platform to take down advertisements for China Central Television (CCTV), a state media channel accused of

Bunny or bird: What do you see in 2019-08-21 10:25:07Is it a bird? Or is it a bunny?

Apple Card starts rolling out for some users 2019-08-06 08:28:06Apple began to roll out its entry into the credit card business, Apple Card, on Tuesday, following comments from CEO Tim Cook last month.

YouTube removes far-right creator Soph's account for hate 2019-08-05 17:50:55Google-owned YouTube has taken down the account of a teenage creator after she posted a video that seemed to call for violence against LGBT people.


Uber tries to reassure customers that it takes 2019-08-24 16:35:21It’s hard at times not to feel sorry for Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi, given all that he inherited when he became the ride-share giant’s top

Y Combinator Demo Day, revenue-based VC funding, Pivotal, 2019-08-24 14:36:58Editor’s note Due to bad travel logistics (thanks SFO), I wasn’t able to get the mid-week edition of the Extra Crunch roundup newsletter o

The new Disney+ streaming service is oriented around 2019-08-24 14:24:54You can tell a lot about a service by what it prioritizes on its home screen. With the new Disney + service the focus is initially organized by fan ba

Driving Volkswagen’s all-electric ID Buggy concept 2019-08-24 13:00:27The VW electric ID Buggy concept is delightful and bright, stout and smiling. It’s a vehicle fit for the sunshine and sand dunes, or perhaps a l

Startups Weekly: Diamond-encrusted disruption 2019-08-24 08:00:32In this week's newsletter: Andreessen Horowitz's latest investment, Pietra, is tackling the $250 billion jewelry market.

Graphcore founder Nigel Toon to talk about AI 2019-08-24 04:01:12It’s easy to forget that Silicon Valley starts with ‘silicon’, and that there would be no technology innovation without innovation a

Confirmed: Disney is making an Obi-Wan series with 2019-08-23 20:38:06The rumors have been suggesting it for a while now, and fans have been pretty much begging for it… and it’s happening: Ewan McGregor will

Here’s the first trailer for the upcoming Disney+ 2019-08-23 20:27:01It’s here! About ten months after we learned that Jon Favreau would be heading up a Star Wars series called “The Mandalorian” on Dis

Vape lung has claimed its first victim, and 2019-08-23 19:57:01A person has died from what the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention speculate is a vaping-related condition. Nearly 200 other cases of varying

Disney introduces “She Hulk”, “Moon Knight” and “Ms. 2019-08-23 19:56:56As part of its big reveal of the slate of shows coming to Disney+ streaming service, Marvel head Kevin Feige introduced three new shows that would be

Trump adds tariffs to $550 billion of Chinese 2019-08-23 19:51:42President Trump announced Friday on Twitter that tariffs on Chinese imports will increase 5 percentage points in a tit-for-tat response to China&rsquo

Bag Week 2019: A whole bunch of fannies 2019-08-23 18:05:11It’s finally Bag Week again! The most wonderful week of the year at TechCrunch. Just in time for back to school, we’re bringing you r


Tesla updates its Autopilot auto lane change animation 2019-08-24 15:34:05 Tesla has made a slight update to its Autopilot auto lane change animation in a new software update this week. more… Subscribe to Electrek on

Tesla Sentry Mode helps police in break-in – 2019-08-24 12:21:21 Tesla Sentry Mode, a security system built into Tesla vehicles, has helped the police in another Tesla break-in in California. Learn people, stop bre

Climate Crisis Weekly: Amazon rain forest fire, the 2019-08-24 09:00:11 In this edition of Climate Crisis Weekly: Just in case you didn’t hear, the Amazon rain forest is on fire. The other Amazon — you know, J

Podcast: Tesla this week, Mercedes-Benz electric minivan, Porsche 2019-08-23 15:36:59 This week on the Electrek Podcast, we discuss the most popular news in the world of sustainable transport and energy, including all the news fro

Tesla announces expansions in Poland, Hungary, Romania, and 2019-08-23 14:15:41 Tesla is finally expanding in Eastern Europe by making its vehicles available to order in Poland, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia starting now. more&h

EGEB: Bernie Sanders’ Green New Deal, Apple’s solar 2019-08-23 14:00:15 In today’s Electrek Green Energy Brief (EGEB): Bernie Sanders announces his Green New Deal. Apple develops rooftop solar for Taiwanese soy sauc

Add Sun Joe’s 14A Electric Pressure Washer to 2019-08-23 13:24:50 Amazon offers the Sun Joe 2030PSI 14A Electric Pressure Washer for $124 shipped. Also at Walmart. Originally $199, it more recently sells for ar

Tesla and Walmart are looking to re-energize 240+ 2019-08-23 12:55:42 Earlier this week, we reported on a dispute between Tesla and Walmart over problems with a massive amount of solar power systems the former installed

Audi teases new electric off-roader and it looks 2019-08-23 12:05:01 Audi is going to bring a few new electric vehicles to the IAA Frankfurt Motor Show next month and today, it teased one of those EVs: an insane-lookin

Toyota will deploy 850 electric vehicles at the 2019-08-23 10:16:04 Toyota is providing the official fleet for the Olympic and Paralympic Games in Tokyo in 2020 and 90% of them will be electric. That’s 850 elect

Electric V2G school bus pilots grow, but schools 2019-08-23 08:29:39 “The batteries on this bus go bi-directional!” That’s what kids in White Plains School District, just north of New York City, can b

Tesla makes battery supply deal with LG for 2019-08-23 05:45:48 Tesla has reportedly signed a battery supply deal with LG Chem for Gigafactory 3 in China. It would be Tesla’s first deal to supply battery cel

Ars Technica UK

The Pebble Beach Concours in pictures: plenty of 2019-08-24 14:40:35But why didn't the world's most beautiful car win best in show?

Ewan McGregor confirms he will return as Obi-Wan 2019-08-24 13:20:56Plus first trailers for What If...? and The Mandalorian; more new series under way.

A lone gunman roams a galaxy in chaos 2019-08-24 10:15:44New series takes place a few years after the fall of the Empire.

Our favorite gaming studios, expos, museum exhibits—in a 2019-08-24 09:00:55Flip through nearly a decade of costumed fans, rare consoles, and much more.

Tracking online hate groups reveals why they’re resilient 2019-08-24 08:15:53When Facebook kicked the KKK, it re-formed on a Russia-based social network.

Book publishers sue Audible to stop new speech-to-text 2019-08-24 07:55:27Publishers say Audible's new captions feature is illegal. Is it?

Why people keep falling for viral hoaxes 2019-08-24 07:15:25How did this latest Instagram hoax spread? Simple: Our dumb brains.

Hackers are actively trying to steal passwords from 2019-08-24 06:30:34Got Fortigate or Pulse Secure? Now would be a good time to make sure they're patched.

Deadly superbug outbreak in humans linked to antibiotic 2019-08-23 17:15:18Use of certain antibiotics in cattle increased 41% just before the outbreak.

Hundreds of “banned” goods still for sale on 2019-08-23 16:08:32WSJ report finds "flea market" environment with scant oversight for merchants.

Vaping-linked lung disease cases jump from 94 to 2019-08-23 16:05:09That's a 60% rise in cases in five days; CDC has since reported even more probable cases.

US phone carriers make empty, unenforceable promises to 2019-08-23 15:51:51All 50 states agree to let telcos keep doing what they're already doing.

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.